| Year | Section 1 Champion | Section 2 Champion | Section 3 Champion | Section 4 Champion | Section 5 Champion |
| 2021 | Hempfield & McCaskey | Lebanon* & Warwick | Cocalico | Lancaster Catholic | Columbia |
| 2020 | Cedar Crest* | Warwick | Lampeter-Strasburg | Lancaster Catholic | Columbia |
| 2019 | Manheim Township* | Warwick | Lampeter-Strasburg | Lancaster Catholic | Lancaster Mennonite |
| Year | Section 1 Champion | Section 2 Champion | Section 3 Champion | Section 4 Champion |
| 2018 | Hempfield | Lampeter-Strasburg* | Lancaster Catholic | Section 4 was eliminated following the 2015-2016 season |
| 2017† | Lebanon | Lampeter-Strasburg | Lancaster Mennonite | |
| 2016 | McCaskey* | Lebanon | Lampeter-Strasburg | Lancaster Catholic |
| 2015 | Cedar Crest* | Conestoga Valley | Manheim Central | Lancaster Mennonite |
| 2014 | Cedar Crest* | Lebanon | Manheim Central | Lancaster Mennonite |
| 2013 | McCaskey* | Elizabethtown | Donegal | Lancaster Catholic |
| 2012† | Manheim Township | Elizabethtown | Lampeter-Strasburg | Lancaster Catholic |
| 2011† | McCaskey | Cocalico | Lamptere-Strasburg | Lancaster Catholic |
| 2010 | Hempfield* | Solanco | Cocalico | Lancaster Catholic |
| 2009† | Hempfield | Elizabethtown | Cocalico | Lancaster Catholic |
| 2008 | McCaskey* | Conestoga Valley | Lebanon | Columbia |
| 2007 | McCaskey* | Solanco | Lebanon | Lancaster Catholic |
| 2006 | McCaskey* | Solanco | Cocalico | Lancaster Catholic |
| 2005† | Manheim Township | Ephrata | Cocalico | Lancaster Catholic |
| Year | Section 1 Champion | Section 2 Champion | Section 3 Champion |
| 2004† | Hempfield | Consetoga Valley | Lancaster Catholic |
| 2003 | McCaskey | Lancaster Mennonite | Lancaster Catholic* |
| 2002 | McCaskey* | Lampeter-Strasburg | Lancaster Catholic |
| 2001 | McCaskey* | Garden Spot | Lancaster Catholic |
| 2000† | McCaskey | Garden Spot | Annville-Cleona |
| 1999 | Hempfield* | Garden Spot | Annville-Cleona |
| 1998 | Manheim Township | Lebanon* | Annville-Cleona |
| 1997 | Hempfield | Lebanon* | ELCO |
| 1996 | McCaskey | Lebanon* | Annville-Cleona |
| 1995 | Hempfield* | Lebanon | Annville-Cleona |
| 1994 | Conestoga Valley | Solanco* | Annville-Cleona |
| 1993† | Lebanon | Ephrata | Lampeter-Strasburg |
| 1992† | Conestoga Valley | Ephrata | ELCO |
| 1991 | Warwick | Conestoga Valley* | Lancaster Mennonite |
| 1990 | Warwick | Columbia* | Northern Lebanon |
| 1989 | McCaskey | Columbia* | Northern Lebnon |
| 1988 | Manheim Township | Warwick* | Annville-Cleona |
| 1987 | Manheim Township | Warwick* | Northern Lebanon |
| 1986 | Lebanon* | Warwick | ELCO |
| 1985 | Lebanon* | Warwick | ELCO |
| 1984† | McCaskey | Warwick | Lebanon Catholic |
| 1983 | McCaskey* | Cocalico | Donegal |
| 1982 | McCaskey* | Warwick | ELCO |
| 1981 | Lebanon | Warwick* | ELCO |
| 1980 | Manheim Central | McCaskey* | Garden Spot |
| 1979 | Cocalico | Lebanon* | Garden Spot |
| 1978 | Cocalico | Lebanon* | Garden Spot |
| 1977 | Cocalico* | Hempfield | Elizabethtown |
| 1976 | Ephrata | Cedar Crest* | Donegal |
| 1975 | Ephrata* | McCaskey | Garden Spot |
| 1974 | McCaskey | Cocalico* | Section 3 was introduced for the 1974-1975 season |
| 1973 | McCaskey* | Cocalico |
*Denotes League Champion
†Hempfield won the League Championship in 1984 and 1992, McCaskey in 1993, Hempfield in 2000, Lebanon in 2004, McCaskey in 2005, Conestoga Valley in 2009, Hempfield in 2011, McCaskey in 2012, Lancaster Catholic in 2017
Special thanks to LLHoops.com who in turn gives credit to Dick Myers of PA Scholastic Sports and Jerry Shenk of Middle Atlantic Sporting news for help in compiling this information. Check out the link for a complete score archive of every game ever played in the LL League Boys Basketball Playoffs.