| Year | Section 1 Champion | Section 2 Champion | Section 3 Champion | Section 4 Champion | Section 5 Champion |
| 2020 | Hempfield | Ephrata | Solanco | Lancaster Catholic* | Lancaster Country Day |
| 2019 | Cedar Crest | Elizabethtown | Solanco | Lancaster Catholic* | Lancaster Mennonite |
| Year | Section 1 Champion | Section 2 Champion | Section 3 Champion | Section 4 Champion |
| 2018 | Manheim Township | Lampeter-Strasburg | Lancaster Catholic* | Section 4 was eliminated following the 2015-16 season |
| 2017 | Cedar Crest* | Lampeter-Strasburg | Northern Lebanon | |
| 2016 | Cedar Crest | Ephrata | Norther Lebanon | Lancaster Catholic* |
| 2015† | McCaskey | Lebanon | Dongeal | Lancaster Catholic |
| 2014 | Manheim Township | Donegal | Lancaster Catholic | |
| 2013 | Manheim Township | Ephrata | Lampeter-Strasburg | Lancaster Catholic* |
| 2012 | Manheim Township | Solanco | Manheim Central | Lancaster Catholic* |
| 2011 | Manheim Township* | Cocalico | Lampeter-Strasburg | Lancaster Catholic |
| 2010 | Cedar Crest* | Solanco | Manheim Central | Lancaster Mennonite |
| 2009 | Manheim Township | Ephrata | Lampeter-Strasburg | Lancaster Mennonite* |
| 2008† | Cedar Crest | Garden Spot | Lampeter-Strasburg | Lancaster Mennonite |
| 2007 | Cedar Crest* | Conestoga Valley | Lebanon | Lancaster Catholic |
| 2006 | McCaskey | Lebanon | Cocalico | Lancaster Catholic* |
| Year | Section 1 Champion | Section 2 Champion | Section 3 Champion |
| 2005 | Hempfield* | Conestoga Valley | Lancaster Catholic |
| 2004 | Cedar Crest* | Elizabethtown | Lancaster Catholic |
| 2003 | Cedar Crest* | Manheim Central | Lancaster Catholic |
| 2002 | Cedar Crest | Manheim Central | Lancaster Catholic* |
| 2001 | Cedar Crest* | Lebanon | ELCO |
| 2000 | Hempfield | Lebanon | Lancaster Catholic* |
| 1999 | Hempfield | Conestoga Valley | ELCO* |
| 1998† | Hempfield | Conestoga Valley | ELCO |
| 1997† | Hempfield | Cocalico | Columbia |
| 1996 | McCaskey* | Conestoga Valley | Cocalico |
| 1995† | Manheim Township | Lancaster Catholic | Lebanon Catholic |
| 1994 | Manheim Township* | Lancaster Catholic | Lebanon Catholic |
| 1993 | Cedar Crest | Lancaster Catholic* | Lebanon Catholic |
| 1992 | Manheim Township | Lancaster Catholic* | Lebanon Catholic |
| 1991 | Warwick* | Ephrata | Lancaster Mennonite |
| 1990 | McCaskey* | Lancaster Catholic | Donegal |
| 1989 | Lancaster Catholic* | Columbia | Annville-Cleona |
| 1988 | Lancaster Catholic* | Warwick | Annville-Cleona |
| 1987 | Manheim Township* | Columbia | Annville-Cleona |
| 1986 | Manheim Township* | Columbia | Northern Lebanon |
| 1985 | Manheim Township* | Ephrata | Lebanon Catholic |
| 1984 | McCaskey* | Ephrata | Donegal |
| 1983 | McCaskey* | Warwick | Donegal |
| 1982 | McCaskey* | Ephrata | Lebanon Catholic |
| 1981 | Lebanon Catholic* | McCaskey | Donegal |
| 1980 | Lebanon | McCaskey | Donegal* |
| 1979 | Lebanon* | McCaskey | Hempfield |
| 1978 | Lebanon* | McCaskey | Hempfield |
| 1977 | Cedar Crest* | McCaskey | Lampeter-Strasburg |
| 1976 | Lebanon* | Lancaster Catholic | Lampeter-Strasburg |
| 1975 | Lebanon | Lancaster Catholic* | Penn Manor |
| 1974 | Garden Spot* | Lebanon | Section 3 was introduced for the 1974-75 season |
| 1973 | Garden Spot* | Lebanon |
*Denotes League Champion
†Columbia won the League Championship in 1995, Manheim Township in 1997, Lancaster Catholic in 1998, Hempfield in 2008, Cedar Crest in 2015
Special Thanks to Jeff Reinhart of PennLive.com and Annville-Celona AD Tommy Long for help in compiling this information.