| Year | AAA Singles Champion | AA Singles Champion | AAA Doubles Champion | AA Doubles Champion |
| 2019 | Catherine Rabatin (Penn Manor) | Riley Smith (Lancaster Catholic) | Avery Palandijan & Scotty Reynolds (Manheim Township) | Riley Smith & Angelle San Jose (Lancaster Catholic) |
| 2018 | Amanda Hagino (Hempfield) | Riley Smith (Lancaster Catholic) | Emily Garvin & Avery Paladjian (Manheim Township) | Riley Smith & Isabel Midcap (Lancaster Catholic) |
| 2017 | Amanda Hagino (Hempfield) | Isabel Midcap (Lancaster Catholic) | Taylor Kopan & Kate Moore (Manheim Township) | Riley Smith & Isabel Midcap (Lancaster Catholic) |
| 2016 | Taylor Kopan (Manheim Township) | Riley Smith (Lancaster Catholic) | Kate Moore & Taylor Kopan (Manheim Township) | Elizabeth Baker & Meredith Debord (Lancaster Catholic) |
| 2015 | Taylor Capoferi (Lampeter-Strasburg) | Maja Anderson (Northern Lebanon) | Carolyn Mann & Kate Moore (Manheim Township) | Alicia Hitz & Emma Lerchen (Annville-Cleona) |
| 2014 | Katina Jones (Penn Manor) | Lil Veronis (Lancaster Catholic) | Sarah Sambrick & Tori Schultz (Lampeter-Strasburg) | Lil Veronis & Ellie /Cubbison (Lancaster Catholic) |
| 2013 | Katina Jones (Penn Manor) | Lil Veronis (Lancaster Catholic) | Emily Mann & Emily Murphy (Manheim Township) | Lil Veronis & Julia Davis (Lancaster Catholic) |
| 2012 | Katina Jones (Penn Manor) | Madelyn Shaak (ELCO) | Emily Mann & Meredith Meyer (Manheim Township) | Madelyn Shaak & Kristi Fidler (ELCO) |
| 2011 | Mackenzie Smith (Hempfield) | Julia Casselbury (Lancaster Country Day) | Lauren Stauffer & Abby Belser (Manheim Township) | Madelyn Shaak & Kristi Fidler (ELCO) |
| 2010 | Mackenzie Smith (Hempfield) | Julia Casselbury (Lancaster Country Day) | Lauren Stauffer & Caroline Barry (Manheim Township) | Sami Davies & Marykate Lemon (Annville-Cleona) |
| 2009 | Leah Rutt (McCaskey) | Julia Casselbury (Lancaster Country Day) | Lauren Stauffer & Caroline Barry (Manheim Township) | Madeylyn Shaak & Ashley Walker (ELCO) |
League champions are the winners of their respective Flight 1 bracket. Click on the year for results from all flights (when available). Girls tennis split to AAA and AA brackets for Flight 1 in 1998, prior to that there was no distinction on school size.