| Year | Section 1 Boys Champion | Section 2 Boys Champion | Section 1 Girls Champion | Section 2 Girls Champion |
| 2022 | Manheim Township* | Ephrata | Warwick* | Ephrata |
| 2021 | Manheim Township* | Ephrata | Manheim Township* | Ephrata |
| 2020 | Manheim Township* | Ephrata | Manheim Township* | Lampeter-Strasburg |
| 2019† | Manheim Township* | Conestoga Valley | Manheim Township | Ephrata |
| 2018† | Manheim Township* | Cocalico | Manheim Township | Ephrata |
| 2017 | Hempfield* | Cocalico | Warwick* | Ephrata |
| 2016 | Hempfield* | Conestoga Valley | Manheim Township* | Cocalico |
| 2015 | Hempfield* | Cocalico | Manheim Township* | Cocalico |
| 2014 | Hempfield* Conestoga Valley |
Lancaster Catholic | Manheim Township* | Cocalico |
| 2013 | Hempfield Manheim Township* Warwick |
Lancaster Catholic | Manheim Township* | Cocalico |
| 2012 | Manheim Township* | Lancaster Catholic | Manheim Township* | Cocalico |
| 2011** | Manheim Township | Lancaster Catholic | Manheim Township | Ephrata |
| Year | Boys Regular Season Champion | Girls Regular Season Champion |
| 2010† | Cedar Crest* | Hempfield |
| 2009† | Manheim Township | Manheim Township |
| 2008 | Manheim Township* | Hempfield* |
| 2007† | Hempfield* Cedar Crest |
Cedar Crest |
| 2006 | Hempfield* | Cedar Crest* |
| 2005† | Cedar Crest | Hempfield* |
| 2004† | Manheim Township | Manheim Township* |
| 2003† | Cedar Crest* Hempfield Manheim Township |
Hempfield |
| 2002 | Manheim Township* | Manheim Township* |
| 2001 | Hempfield* Manheim Township |
Cedar Crest* |
*Denotes All League Meet Team Champion
†All League Meet Girls Champion in 2003 was Manheim Township, Boys Champion in 2004 was Cedar Crest, Boys Champion in 2005 was Hempfield, Girls Champion in 2007 was Hempfield, 2009 Boys Champion was Hempfield, 2009 Girls Champion was Hempfield, 2010 Girls Champion was Manheim Township, 2018 and 2019 Girls Champion was Warwick
**In 2011 Hempfield and Manheim Township tied for both the Girls and Boys All League Meet Team Championships
Special thanks to Mr. Andrew Amway in helping to compile this information.