| Year | Section 1 Champion | Section 2 Champion | Section 3 Champion |
| 2020 | Hempfield* | Garden Spot | Northern Lebanon |
| 2019† | Conestoga Valley | Lampeter-Strasburg | Northern Lebanon |
| 2018 | Cocalico | Manheim Central* | Northern Lebanon |
| 2017 | Conestoga Valley Cocalico Penn Manor |
Manheim Central | Northern Lebanon* |
| 2016 | Solanco | Cocalico | Northern Lebanon* |
| 2015† | Solanco | Conestoga Valley | Northern Lebanon |
| 2014 | Hempfield Solanco* |
Garden Spot | Northern Lebanon |
| 2013† | Solanco | Conestoga Valley | Northern Lebanon |
| 2012 | Solanco* | Manheim Central | Donegal |
| 2011 | Solanco* | Garden Spot | Annville-Cleona |
| 2010 | Solanco* | Elizabethtown | Annville-Cleona |
| 2009 | Warwick* | Elizabethtown | Annville-Cleona ELCO |
| 2008 | Warwick | Elizabethtown* | Donegal |
| 2007 | Warwick* | Elizabethtown | Donegal |
| 2006 | Penn Manor | Manheim Central* | Donegal |
| 2005 | Hempfield* | Manheim Central | Dongeal |
| 2004† | Penn Manor | Manheim Central | Cocalico |
| 2003 | Penn Manor | Ephrata* | Cocalico |
| 2002† | Solanco | Lampeter-Strasburg | Cocalico ELCO Columbia |
| 2001 | Hempfield* | Ephrata | Donegal |
| 2000† | Ephrata | Manheim Central | Lampeter-Strasburg |
| 1999 | Hempfield | Solanco* | Donegal |
| 1998 | Hempfield | Solanco* | Lampeter-Strasburg |
| 1997 | Warwick | Manheim Central* | Lampeter-Strasburg |
| 1996 | Warwick* | Elizabethtown | Cocalico |
| 1995 | Solanco | Manheim Central | Cocalico |
| Year | Section 1 Champion | Section 2 Champion |
| 1994 | Warwick | Northern Lebanon |
| 1993 | Solanco | Cocalico |
| 1992 | Solanco | Cocalico Lampeter-Strasburg |
| 1991 | Ephrata | Cocalcico |
| 1990 | Manheim Central | Cocalico |
| 1989 | Manheim Central | Cocalico |
| 1988 | Manheim Central Hempfield |
Garden Spot |
| 1987 | Manheim Central | Donegal |
| 1986 | Manheim Central | Pequea Valley |
| 1985 | Warwick | Lampeter-Strasburg |
| 1984 | Warwick Solanco |
Lampeter-Strasburg |
| 1983 | Warwick Lancaster Catholic |
Donegal |
| 1982 | Warwick | Columbia |
| 1981 | Warwick | Lancaster Catholic |
| 1980 | Warwick | Lancaster Catholic |
| 1979 | Warwick | Donegal |
| 1978 | Warwick Elizabethtown |
Penn Manor Donegal |
| 1977 | Warwick | Donegal |
| 1976 | Warwick Manheim Central |
Annville-Cleona |
| 1975 | Manheim Township | Donegal |
| 1974 | Manheim Township | Elizabethtown |
| 1973 | Manheim Township | Elizabethtown |
*Denotes team champion as determined at the LL League tournament
†Hempfield won the team championship in 2000, Ephrata in 2002, Hempfield in 2004, Manheim Township in 2013, Penn Manor in 2015, Manheim Central in 2019
Special Thanks to Mr. Dave Byrne at Lancaster Newspapers in helping to compile this information.